Closed systems collapse, open ones thrive: the Health Design Challenge

Next guest post by SPM member and former health system executive @NickDawson.

Ilya Prigogine received in the Nobel Prize in Chemistry in 1977. His work largely focused on Non-equilibrium thermodynamics. What he found is as fascinating for scientists and non-scientists alike. It turns out, according to Prigogine, closed systems are destined to collapse or fail. Open systems, by contrast, will usually grow and evolve[1][2].

Healthcare is notorious for its closed systems. We see painful reminders in restrictions on accessing our own health data. And it goes deeper. The processes, experiences and governance of health systems has also been, historically, closed. Today, healthcare represents a huge 18% of our gross domestic product. And, according to the WHO, the United States is 37th in the world in terms of outcomes.

It would seem Prigogine is correct. Closed systems tend to fail. Thankfully, that is changing.

In 2012, a consortium called d*collab put forth a challenge: design a better health record. The challenge had 4 objectives:

  • Improve the visual layout and style of the information from the medical record
  • Create a human-centered design that makes it easier for patient to manage their health
  • Enable health professionals to more effectively understand and use patients’ health information
  • Help family members and friends care for their loved ones

The results are on display on the Health Design Challenge site.

What is so compelling about this idea is its openness. The various designs are all freely available. George Bernard Shaw is credited with the maxim: “If you have an apple and I have an apple and we exchange these apples then you and I will still each have one apple. But if you have an idea and I have an idea and we exchange these ideas, then each of us will have two ideas.”

Design challenges, like the Health Design Challenge, offer an opportunity to freely exchange ideas. These are inherently open systems where ideas are traded and built upon like Lego blocks. The fantastic thing about a design challenge is that it does not have to be limited to visual elements, such as medical records.

Processes, doctor patient communication, billing cycles, and entire organizational strategies can be openly designed. There is an important role for patients in these design challenges too. One can imagine a time when open, patient-driven design challenges are part of a competitive edge for savvy healthcare organizations. And, according to Prigogine, those are the systems which remain viable now and into the future.

  1. Al Gore Has Big Plans. New York Times, May 20, 2007
  2. Gore, Albert. The Future: Six Drivers of Global Change. (2013). Random House. Available at Amazon.
Print

Posted in: trends & principles

 

 

Comments

2 Responses to “Closed systems collapse, open ones thrive: the Health Design Challenge”

  1. Don’t you love before & afters? Whether it’s a kitchen redesign or a beauty makeover, I’m all over it.

    That’s why I loved the re-designs at http://healthdesignchallenge.com. The best features among the winning designs were–
    1) Test results with explanations of the results in standard English. I don’t have to figure out if low LDL is good or bad. The record explains it all. (Nightingale)
    2) Medical history timeline. Love the graphic that shows me visually what health events in my life happened when. That tetanus booster was when? I can see it at a glance. (Blue Button by Method.
    3) Trends over time. Another wonderful graphic. Does my cholesterol reading on one day matter as much as my cholesterol year after year? It’s the trend! (Stay Well by Teague and others)
    I hope that the patient record vendors are paying attention to this kind of innovation.

  2. Nick Dawson says:

    Patricia – you’ve captured a whole different angle to the Design Challenge, it’s one I’m really compelled by.

    If I were a record vendor, I’d fly every one of these designers and anyone from SPM who was interested in for a week of brainstorming…can you imagine what kind of ideas and designs would come out of that?

Leave a Reply